Dunbar High School: How Did Black Students Lead D.C.?
By Tanya Brooks, PowerVault Staff Dunbar High School students topped citywide tests given in Black and white Washington schools as early as 1899, decades after its church basement beginnings. That receipt deserves mor...

By Tanya Brooks, PowerVault Staff
Dunbar High School students topped citywide tests given in Black and white Washington schools as early as 1899, decades after its church basement beginnings.
That receipt deserves more than a quick Black history repost. The school that became Paul Laurence Dunbar High opened in 1870 as the Preparatory High School for Colored Youth. It was the nation’s first public high school for Black students. Its record demands a better conversation about what Black education can look like.
Author Alison Stewart described those beginnings in NPR’s July 29, 2013, interview about her book First Class. The school “started in 1870 with four students in the basement of a church,” she said. Free Black Washington residents organized to establish it after the Civil War.
The school’s documented history identifies that location as Fifteenth Street Presbyterian Church and credits school trustee William Syphax with starting it. From 1891 through 1916, it operated as M Street High School. The Dunbar name arrived in 1916, honoring poet Paul Laurence Dunbar.
That distinction matters. The students leading those 1899 tests attended M Street, the same institution later named Dunbar. The academic paper “Insights from research on Dunbar High School,” published through AABRI, reports their first place performance. This was measurable achievement against schools serving white students, not a compliment handed out for effort.
College attendance offers another striking measure. The AABRI paper estimates that approximately 80 percent of M Street and Dunbar graduates attended college across the 85 years it examines. Most Americans, Black or white, did not attend college during that period. That figure concerns graduates, not every student who ever enrolled.
The alumni list gives those numbers faces. Stewart named artist Elizabeth Catlett, jazz musician Billy Taylor and Charles Hamilton Houston, an architect of school desegregation. Dunbar also educated Benjamin O. Davis Sr., the Army’s first Black general, and Robert C. Weaver, the first Black presidential Cabinet member. Please give the institution its flowers, too.
White approval was never the source of Black intelligence.
PVN’s take: calling these graduates exceptional should not make their education disappear from the picture. Celebrating individual brilliance feels good. Recognizing the teachers and community behind it asks more of everybody. Those students deserve credit for their work without being cast as people who succeeded entirely on their own.
The system lesson sits in the faculty details. Dunbar teachers earned pay equal to Washington’s white public school teachers, according to the school’s history. Almost all held graduate degrees, and several had doctorates. Treating educators as professionals belongs near the center of this story, not tucked beneath the famous alumni.
The audience lesson needs saying, too: White approval was never the source of Black intelligence. The test comparison matters because it challenges assumptions about Black students. But making white performance the permanent measuring stick would shrink Dunbar’s legacy. Its graduates mattered beyond the scoreboards they topped.
There is a class question here that a victory lap cannot answer. Dunbar was an academically elite public school, and some Black parents moved to Washington so their children could attend. Its results deserve celebration without pretending they describe every Black student’s access. The stronger question is how to make opportunity less dependent on an address.
The faculty roster makes the school’s intellectual depth hard to miss. Anna Julia Cooper served as a teacher and principal. Mary Church Terrell also taught there. Carter G. Woodson, the historian known as the father of Black History Month, was another faculty member. These were thinkers helping shape Black public life while educating students.
That roster should change how the basement beginning gets framed. Humble space did not mean small ambition. Dunbar emerged from an existing commitment to education, not a sudden discovery that Black children could learn.
The racial politics require precision. A Black school’s success under segregation does not make segregation the reason it succeeded. Dunbar’s own Houston helped build the legal campaign against school segregation. His presence in this history makes any attempt to turn the school into an argument for unequal access especially thin.
The record also shows how much access mattered outside Washington. Until 1954, Fairfax County, Virginia, had no secondary schools for Black students. Dunbar and other District public schools accepted students from that county. For those families, crossing a jurisdictional boundary could mean reaching an education their own county did not provide.
There is a useful connection to PVN’s coverage of Beyoncé’s BeyGOOD support for teen literacy. Recognition can draw attention to learning. The harder editorial question is what remains after the applause: Who teaches, who gets access, and what support can students count on?
Preserving the full record matters just as much. The ownership question behind PVN’s look at DJ Screw’s Grey Tapes has a useful parallel here. Black history deserves care beyond its most shareable headline. Names, dates and institutional memory keep a powerful story from becoming a convenient slogan.
Dunbar’s later struggles belong in that record, too. That was a report about conditions then, not a verified description of the school today. Neither its early success nor that later figure should erase the students and educators behind the other.
Those numbers also measure different things. College attendance among graduates cannot be directly compared with a graduation rate. Treating them as one clean rise and fall would produce drama, not understanding. The supplied evidence does not establish a single cause for the school’s later difficulties, and nostalgia cannot fill that gap.
Advertisement
The next conversation should move past amazement that Black students excelled. Dunbar offers documented reasons to examine teacher preparation, professional pay, community commitment and access together, without claiming one school supplies every answer. Give the pioneers their flowers, then ask what today’s students need to flourish. Black children should not need a historic test score to deserve that investment.
More from PowerVault Network:





